| 1 | Indiana 28-21 | Tom Shatel, Omaha World-Herald |
| 1 | Nebraska 27-23 | Make Schaefer, Husker247 |
| 1 | Nebraska 27-24 | Brian Christopherson, Husker247 |
| 1 | Nebraska 28-25 | Michael Bruntz, Husker247 |
| 1 | Nebraska 24-21 | Steven Sipple, HuskerOnline |
| 1 | Nebraska 34-31 | Robin Washut, HuskerOnline |
| 1 | Nebraska 27-20 | Andy Kendeigh, KETV |
| 1 | Nebraska 31-17 | Jim Rose, KFAB |
| 1 | Nebraska 28-27 | Eric Olson, Associated Press |
| 1 | Indiana 30-21 | The Hoosier (Rivals) staff consensus |
| 1 | Indiana win | Scooby Axson, USA Today |
| 1 | Indiana win | Jordan Mendoza, USA Today |
| 1 | Nebraska win | Paul Myerberg, USA Today |
| 1 | Indiana win | Erick Smith, USA Today |
| 1 | Indiana win | Eddie Timanus, USA Today |
| 1 | Nebraska win | Dan Wolken, USA Today |
| 1 | Nebraska 27-24 | HuskerMax/SI writers consensus |
| 1 | Indiana 31-21 | Michael Niziolek, Bloomington Herald-Times |
| 1 | Indiana 27-21 | Sam McKewon, Omaha World-Herald |
| 1 | Indiana 30-24 | Pete Fiutak, College Football News |
| 1 | Indiana by <7 | Dennis Dodd, CBS Sports |
| 1 | Nebraska win | Tom Fornelli, CBS Sports |
| 1 | Indiana by >6 | Chip Patterson, CBS Sports |
| 1 | Indiana by <7 | Shehan Jeyarajah, CBS Sports |
| 1 | Indiana by <7 | David Cobb, CBS Sports |
| 1 | Indiana by <7 | Jerry Palm, CBS Sports |
| 1 | Indiana by <7 | Brandon Marcello, CBS Sports |
| 1 | Nebraska win | Richard Johnson, CBS Sports |
| 1 | Nebraska 21-17 | Amie Just, Lincoln Journal Star |
| 1 | Nebraska 28-24 | Luke Mullin, Lincoln Journal Star |
| 1 | Nebraska 28-24 | Nate Head, Lincoln Journal Star |
| 1 | Indiana 28-21 | Matt Olberding, Lincoln Journal Star |
| 1 | Nebraska 34-27 | Mike'l Severe, Big Red Wrap-Up |
| 1 | Nebraska 28-24 | Jay Moore, Big Red Wrap-Up |
| 1 | Nebraska 31-27 | Sean Callahan, Big Red Wrap-Up |
| 1 | Indiana 31-27 | Dalton Wasserman, Pro Football Focus |
| 1 | Nebraska 28-24 | Max Chadwick, Pro Football Focus |
| 1 | Indiana win | 3 of 3 Athlon staffers |
| 1 | Indiana 30-23 | David Kenyon, Bleacher Report |
| 1 | Indiana 31-24 | Chris Hummer, 247Sports |
| 1 | Nebraska 30-27 | Brad Crawford, 247Sports |
| 1 | Nebraska 28-24 | Adam Carriker |
| 1 | Indiana 30-27 | Bill Bender, Sporting News |
| 1 | Indiana 63.7% win prob. | BCF Toys |
| 1 | Indiana 67.0% win prob. | DRatings |
| 1 | Indiana 67.7% win prob. | numberFire |
| 1 | Indiana 25-20 | SP+ |
| 1 | Indiana 76.7% win prob. | ESPN FPI |